A very interesting deck. After looking the list and some testing, I have these questions:

The possibility of a Crucible lock is tempting, why it didn't make the cut?
What synergy has Cabal Therapy? There isn't enough creatures to play it from the graveyard, besides the "oathable" creatures.

Sometimes I draw a creature, and without any way to put it back to the library, it becomes a liability; is there any way to get around this?

Why not Yawgmoth's Will? With all the Rituals you could play a couple of bombs from the graveyard and turn the tide in your favour.

I agree with the majority of points, but I would like to stress a couple of things:


About "Five Things Type One Needs":

Plus, if Vintage becomes really popular, all the P9 (or any other old card, for instance) in the world would not be enough.
There is a very limited supply of those cards, so proxies would seem a fine solution.

I didn't understand this point. What do you mean? A minimum age threshold to play the format?


About "Five Things Vintage Does Not Need":

Although Wizards does not need to design Vintage-specific cards, it would be nice to have a couple of Vintage-playable cards in each set.