TheManaDrain.com
February 07, 2026, 03:13:48 pm *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News:
 
  Home Help Search Calendar Login Register  
  Show Posts
Pages: [1]
1  Eternal Formats / Global Vintage Tournament Reports and Results / Re: [UPDATE] Vintage Championship in France Top33 and Top8 Unpo on: May 19, 2005, 04:46:59 pm
Quote
Now, you've implied that that one deck tries to play like 4CC but finish off the opponent with Tog (by stating that the advantage from 4CC that deck uses is its ability to control the board).  If it wants to play like 4CC, it should be using Scrying.

I think in order to finish the opponent you shouldn't abuse of the Scrying ... 4cc had an Angel to gain life...

Quote
Actually, we are here to criticize in this way.  This website is devoted to Type 1 discussion and improving the general state of the meta.  Thus it is our responsibility to call bad reasoning when we see it, and explain why.  Do not expect to get treated with kid gloves, because that is not what this site is about.

Yeah, yeah I was just asking for respect not blame and that's what I expected from you guys .
Blaming somebody gives him good reasons not to litsen to your pieces of advice.
2  Eternal Formats / Global Vintage Tournament Reports and Results / Re: [UPDATE] Vintage Championship in France Top33 and Top8 Unpo on: May 19, 2005, 06:46:04 am
Quote
Balance isn't so great against any deck running squees, bazaar, and madness creatures.

Sorry for the misunderstanding. In my reply the cards to handle Madness wasn't only Balance but on the front row: Strip Mine, Wasteland and Swords to Plowshares.

Quote
If you resolve cranial extraction against dragon, the card you name is "Worldgorger Dragon" and that's about it.

Doing this doesn't allows you to win the game for sure...

Quote
paying 4 mana for a non-rebable, non-misdirectable ancestral > paying 5 mana for a non-misdirectable ancestral.

Yeah indeed but you forgot something: in 4CC you run about 1 FoF, 3 or 4 Skeletal Scrying which depends on your graveyard's size and your life points ( to a lower extent) while in ToG or ToGer you have 4 AK, 3 Intuition, 2 DA ( searchable with Intuition because Intuition doesn't search only AKs ).


Quote
(people HAVE bothered to read that you need to keep paying mana to untap with DoD, right?)

The mana base of Dragon allows it not to destroy its own lands with Titan, that's why 2 manas aren't that expansive. And what would you do with those 2 manas? Once Titi is reanimated, you just have to beatdown!

Quote
This is horrible reasoning.
Sad

I think that we ain't here to critcize ourselves this way. I just expose you the point not blaming on your meta or your thoughts about the builds.

Monk, Temper, temper...
3  Eternal Formats / Global Vintage Tournament Reports and Results / Caller or Witness on: May 17, 2005, 07:45:26 am
Quote
As far as running caller over witness there is accutally nothing to say that can convince me that the caller is better in anyway unless you a are a fan of winning one round later in the game.

You don't seem to understand that both of them shows pros or cons. In your case you don't spot the Witness' cons and only see the Caller's.

Let me explain:

Eternal Witness:
In order to kill you must have at least : 2 animate spells (in graveyard  and 1  in hand), 1 Wgr Dragon, 1 Ancestral Recall or 1 Time Walk ( this kill is so complex that I don't remember exactly how to do it ).
In a nutshell, you bring back Dragon with a random enchant dead creature, take infinite colored mana, activate BoB until the win conditions are in the grave, enchant Witness which targets the second "enchant: dead creature" which will reanimate the Dragon, loops goes on and all your grave is in your hand then infinite Ancestral Recall on your opponent. That's great against Gaea's Blessing or DSC.

But what if your opponent has one of those things:
a Lava Dart ( 1 more animate spell is needed )
an E Plague naming human or shaman ( random bouncespell needed )
CotV with 1 counter ( same )
True Believer (same)
Root Maze (same)
Meddling Mage put by Ather Vial

And if you can't have your blue mana for some reasons like Blood Moon, Null Rod, Strip Mine or Wasteland what would you do?
- Nothing... Sad
Even Intuition can't save you all the time when there is no BoB.

But,
Caller of the Claw:
To kill you need 1 Dragon in graveyard, 1 Caller in grave,an animate spell you can cast ( Necromancy in the best case) and/ or a Time Walk to kill imediately.
To search and set the combo you need: 1 BoB or Compulse if Caller isn't already in the grave.
But the biggest difference is that you don't need any mana once the loop begins !

And Caller isn't spoiled by the haters I listed for Witness and can win with Intuition.

Quote
unless you a are a fan of winning one round later in the game

Necromancy can be played as an instant too  Wink

And it beats Gaea's Blessing too.

I stiil don't understand why you're keeeping on denying that there cannot be another Dragon.dec build that can win ...
4  Eternal Formats / Global Vintage Tournament Reports and Results / Re: Vintage Championship in France Top8 on: May 17, 2005, 03:57:31 am
Gentlemen, i still don't understand why you're underestimating the french level Sad
What a shame because you miss something, I personaly think that you're wrong saying that that european top8 isn't relevant.

Quote
To Stephane, why Dance of the Dead over Animate #3?  Is Meddling Mage a problem or something?

And what's the problem with DoD?
It has the same CC than Animate Dead and it is used the same way. And if it was the case, I'd rather not loosing time because of a Meddling Mage or a Cranial extraction.

Quote
Why did he choose the Ambassador/Caller setup over Witness ?

The reason is simple: the wincon is aviable with Inuition which can be done without BoB.

Quote
To Paul, why White of all colors in Psychatog

If you didn't notice it, it's not totally a ToG deck. I'd say it's more like a crossover between 4cc and ToG. It takes the advantages from both of them.

4cc: the "rule-the-game" items like Swords to Plowshares, Wasteland, Strip Mine, Disenchant and Balance which allows him to handle Madness and its BoB for instance.

ToG: the kill "hulk", and the draw engine far better than 4cc's.

Note: You should also notice that he made this by himself and he is only 15. That's why saying it was luck or that the european level is so "low" is totally out of the question. Moreover he beated Carsten Kötter with "that" deck.

Oh, by the way it's name is ToG-er (ToG- Keeper).

Monk (who still doesn't understand why people ain't happy to see some new decks in top 8).
Pages: [1]
Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.032 seconds with 17 queries.