I've replaced the voidmage prodigies maindecked fire/ice. There are a bunch of Fish decks and Workshop decks in my meta, and fire/ice is strong against both of these. In the mirror, Fire is clearly a good card, and is un-misdirectionable in most cases. Against workshop decks, Fire can kill welders and metalworkers. In addition, I sometimes use Ice to slow down the Workshop player early on, in order to get a standstill "lock" before spheres of resistance and wastelands become too much of a problem.
They are useful against aggro, too - better in most aggro matchups than a Prodigy in my opinion. The counter-ability rarely comes into play because it's so slow in this case, so the mage usually just chump blocks and dies. Fire/Ice isn't incredible either, but it's never a dead card. Fish usually has a pretty good matchup against pure control decks with all of the mana denial and manlands, so the change from Voidmage to Fire/Ice isn't as curcial in this case.

more to play. [Oracle 1999/05/01]