TheManaDrain.com
November 11, 2025, 10:11:16 am *
Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.

Login with username, password and session length
News:
 
   Home   Help Search Calendar Login Register  
Pages: [1]
  Print  
Author Topic: Report with Keeper: Best Ebony Charm ever  (Read 3551 times)
carl
Guest
« on: July 22, 2002, 03:04:26 am »

Hello,
After a disappointing 4-1-2, I didn't plan to write a report, but since I enjoy
reading them, it's payback time.
I've decided I would attend the Duelmen monthly T1 10 days ago. I was wondering
what to play, knowing there would be good workshop decks and control.
I settled on Keeper that I hadn't played since last January in a local tourney.
I wanted to give a try to Cunning Wish, so here is what I came with:

The Great Gatsby

1 Balance
1 Dismantling Blow
1 Swords to Plowshares
1 Regrowth
1 Sylvan Library
1 Gorilla Shaman
1 Demonic Tutor
1 Diabolic Edict
1 Mind Twist
1 The Abyss
1 Yawgmoth's Will
1 Ancestral Recall
1 Braingeyser
1 Cunning Wish
1 Fact or Fiction
4 Force of Will
4 Mana Drain
1 Merchant Scroll
1 Misdirection
2 Morphling
1 Mystical Tutor
1 Stroke of Genius
1 Time Walk
1 Fire/Ice
1 Black Lotus
5 Moxen
1 Sol Ring
1 Zuran Orb
4 City of Brass
1 Library of Alexandria
1 Strip Mine
3 Tundra
4 Underground Sea
1 Undiscovered Paradise
4 Volcanic Island
3 Wasteland

Sideboard:
2 CoP Red
1 Moat
2 Swords to Plowshares
4 Red Elemental Blast
1 Ebony Charm
1 Blue Elemental Blast
1 Teferi's Response
2 Powder Keg
1 Scrying Glass

Thanks to everybody who helped me with the sideboard.

I get up at six, goes back to my parents to steal some music and take my watch I
thought I had forgotten there, but couldn't find it. I hate when I don't know
how long there is left in a round. Anyway, I met the other players from Brussels
at 7 am and it turns out they didn't sleep at all, so Paul and Dilson sleep in
the car while I follow Jacques, Vincent and Swap. We are there at 10 am, so we
play some more Type I. The five others are entering the Type II tournament. I
meet Benjamin Rott who is with Dragon.dec and see some face that where there
last time I attended. Only Oliver Daems is missing, busy studying. There are 66
players for a 7 rounds straight swiss tournament.

Round 1: Carsten Spittman - Mono-black
Carsten is quite vocal about his hand, he actually drew 3 Mishra's Factory.
He's drops a Hyppie, I Edict, but he rather sacs a Factory. He grabs my Balance,
I drop Abyss and find 2 Wasteland to get rid of the buggers. I am in control and
drop Morphling to take the first game.
I sideboard in StoP.
In game 2, he drops a Scuta which I drain to allow a 2nd turn Morphling. He
plops another Scuta which goes promply farming. He tutors for an Edict and kills
Morphling. 3 Specters are soon staring at me. Time for a Yawgmoth's Will to send
a Hyppie farming and bring back Superman. He tutors again for an Edict, attacks
with 2 specters to grab my lone card, a Drain, then Edict. I top deck Fact or
Fiction: Drain and Plow or DT, Mox and a land. I take the former and dispatch
the 3rd Hyppie. He sings an Hymn to Tourach that I drain to fuel a Geyser (for
7) that my Mystical Tutor was kind enough to bring me. The rest is history.

Round 2: Tobias Luodvici - 5 colour Oath
Game 1 is fast and furious: Tobias goes for an aggressive Balance, I discard a
land (2 in play) and a random spell, keeping Drain and something else. I don't
draw any other land, Tobias drops a Trike which goes all the way.
Game 2, I drop an early Scrying Glass which Tobias matches with a Powder Keg,
followed by a Scrying Glass of his own. Things look grim, but my Kicked Blow
resolves, as well as Mind Twist. I love this card Smile Morphling does his job.
In the decider, another Mind Twist from my side, keeping a Volcanic Island open.
Tobias goes for Divert (which he plays main deck, interestingly), but I have REB
backup. His top decked Stroke is Force of Willed, his Keg drained. What to do
with 2 colourless? Top deck a Morphling of course. Another game for Superman.

Round 3: Thorsten Dachrodt - Dragon.dec
Last time we met, he was playing control and I combo. Time for revenge for him.
Game 1 goes to him thanks to Duress which disrupt me enough to allow him to
combo me (Whispers of The Muse into Cunning Wish to get Stroke of Genius). His
deck looks well rounded.
Game 2 goes to Library of Alexandria: he doesn't play and land destruction, so I
sit back and watch him trying to escape the net I am weaving around him. He
concedes before I drop Morphling to have a chance to take...
Game 3: I get another Library of Alexandria (I think it was brought to me by my
Demonic Tutor). Thorsten is severly mana screwed, he discarded a lot. Strip Mine
and Wasteland didn't help him, nor did Mind Twist.
Thorsten will have to wait some more to get his revenge Wink

Round 4: Joachim Haupt - Dragon.dec
Joachim is sporting another version of the latest fad, with the Squee + Bazaar
of Bagdad engine.
Game 1, Joachim has to mulligan, I Mind Twist for 2 turn 1, Fact or Fiction turn
2, and he never comes back. I am not sure what he is playing, so I leave 2 Plow
in the board.
Game 2, I Ancestral in his upkeep, he Misdirects it, I Force but he drains. He
gets his engine going, but is quite slow to pull the combo.
This leaves us 15 minutes to finish game 3. I am quickly in control, but take
time to find a Morphling. Time is called, and after the 5th turn, I have him at
4 life. Remember that watch I couldn't find? Sad

Round 5: Falk Bernhardt - Miracle Grow
I get yet another early Library of Alexandria, and he is not playing any strips.
He drops a Werebear, gets threshold, drops a Meddling Mage naming 'Balance'. I
drop a Morphling with only one blue open. He Plows, I make it untargetable, he
Plows again in response, I Misdirect it on his Werebear and kill him.
Game 2, he counters my stroke for 3, counters my Moat with Foil, emptying his
hand. I Y's Will Moat, get out Abyss, waiting for Morphling. At some point he
drops the bugger: Winter Orb. I DT for Shaman and kill it. I am hiding behind
the Library of Alexandria which provides me a Morphling to take the match.

Round 6: Benjamin Ribbeck - Tools 'n Tubbies
This is the match I was looking forward to play. Benjamin and his friends have
taken advantage of the Incarnations from Judgement. Since Wonder and Anger ask
for Island and Mountain respectively, they have decided to includ Land Grant. I
like the way they are tweaking what I consider the current best T1 aggro deck.
In the first game, I Merchant Scroll for Ancestral, but Benjamin strips my lone
blue source, and I don't draw any other for long enough to allow him to kill me.
Game 2, I draw enough counter to keep him at bay, then Mind Twist his hand away.
He doesn't look to bothered, as he now has Anger, Wonder and Genesis in his
graveyard. This is until I make him read Ebony Charm, of course. I stay in
control and after a Yawgmoth's Will to allow another Mind Twist, he concedes.
He starts game 3 with a Su-Chi which I send farming. He follows with Trike and
Tinker into a Memory Jar. Next turn, he sacs his Jar after attacking me with the
Trike. Waste my second blue opened. I take the mana Smile he taps GRU and plays
Welder. I've got a BEB in my hand, but think he is bluffing, so I drain it. He
drops Survival of the Fittest :/ We go back to our regular hand, and I don't
have a solution to his enchantment. So, I top deck the Blow, play it with
kicker. I play Moat, but he has Wonder in his graveyard. I waste his lone
Island, a Tropical one. His plan is to recycle his 2 Triskelion with a Welder to
kill me. I Fact or Fiction when time is called and choose Zuran Orb and a land
rather than Swords, a land and a blue card. I should be okay, but in the second
extra turn, he Time Walks, I Force, he REBs. This looks bad for me, as this
allows him to do 3 more damage with his engine. In the fifth turn, he recycle a
last time a Triskelion while I am at 2. He activates his Trike to deal one
damage. In response, I sac a land to try to go to 4 life. He activates his Trike
twice in response to bring me to 0 life. And it's here that I can shout: BEST
EBONY CHARM EVER, because I cast it to drain him for one. He has to read it
again, and the grin he had on his face suddenly vanishes, as we draw the match.

Round 7: Carsten Kötter - Powered Grim Monolith
From what I could see, Carsten is playing a deck similar to my twister.dec, but
he is killing with Power Artifact and Grim Monolith to generate 'infinite' mana
and kill with Geyser or Stroke. We are playing for a place in the top 8.
Game 1, we exchange some strips, he doesn't drop lands for 2-3 turns, then gets
Library of Alexandria out. I don't have another Wasteland, but top deck a Strip
Mine. He stole only 2 cards. He then tutors once, twice, and gets the engine
going. I look at the 17 cards I've draw since the beginning of the game: 14 mana
source, Time Walk, Dismantling Blow and Morphling. Not enough to stop his combo,
obviously.
I get turn 1 Shaman, which annoys him. I get him down to 6, then when I think he
is out of counter, I drop Morphling and it hits. But I hadn't seen he was
holding Demonic Tutor which happily grabs a Balance that I have no answer for.
We are both down to 1 card, I have Scrying Glass out, but he recovers faster
than me. Oh yes, I forgot: his lone card was a Yawgmoth's Will, allowing his to
bring back a 2nd Negator and Time Walk to make sure I can't put enough counters
on my Keg to blow up his world. Type I is broken.

I am quite disappointed with the loss in the last round, but that's Magic.
Benjamin Ribbeck beat Kai Budde (playing Trix) in the last round to take the
tournament and the Library of Alexandria as first prize. Dragon.dec didn't put
an impressive showing, as expected.

Keeper is not bad, but why does it have to poop on you one round in the tourney?

Check out the decklists at http://www.morphling.de/ in a few days.
Logged
CrazyCarl
Guest
« Reply #1 on: July 22, 2002, 03:42:19 am »

Always a pleasure to read a tourney report .  Nicely done.

How was the Cunning Wish for you?

Carl
Logged
carl
Guest
« Reply #2 on: July 22, 2002, 07:31:44 am »

Quote from: CrazyCarl+July 22 2002,10:42
Quote (CrazyCarl @ July 22 2002,10:42)Always a pleasure to read a tourney report Very Happy.  Nicely done.

Thanks.

Quote
Quote How was the Cunning Wish for you?

Well, I drew it only twice and grabbed Teferi's Response (against a mono-black packing Sinkhole and vs the mirror), and I ended pitching them to Force of Will. So, I wasn't overly impressed, but I still keep it for further testing. I should especially try the Shattering Pulse.
Logged
Fishhead
Guest
« Reply #3 on: July 22, 2002, 03:23:28 pm »

Thanks for the report.  

Can you talk a bit about the changes to the Workshop deck?  I played a version of Thomas Elgerts winning deck from the last Dulmen tourney; theres a report in a thread called "T1 Norcal with Spevack & Co".  

Anyway, my two major changes were to put Genesis and Wonder in.  I thought Anger would not be good enough; but I will have to reconsider that in light of your comments.  

The Land Grants seem like an interesting idea; though I'm not sure how I would adjust my mana base to make this make sense.  I am already running just 4xTaiga, 3xTropical and 4xCity as colored mana.  I could cut the Cities in favor of Land Grants or I could start cutting into my Wastelands.  Neither of these seems that attractive.
Logged
teletubby
Guest
« Reply #4 on: July 23, 2002, 06:08:22 pm »

Quote from: Fishhead+July 22 2002,16:23
Quote (Fishhead @ July 22 2002,16:23)Can you talk a bit about the changes to the Workshop deck?  I played a version of Thomas Elgerts winning deck from the last Dulmen tourney; theres a report in a thread called "T1 Norcal with Spevack & Co".  

Anyway, my two major changes were to put Genesis and Wonder in.  I thought Anger would not be good enough; but I will have to reconsider that in light of your comments.  

The Land Grants seem like an interesting idea; though I'm not sure how I would adjust my mana base to make this make sense.  I am already running just 4xTaiga, 3xTropical and 4xCity as colored mana.  I could cut the Cities in favor of Land Grants or I could start cutting into my Wastelands.  Neither of these seems that attractive.
You can see the decklists of the top 8 on www.morphling.de.
Or just follow this link: http://www.morphling.de/turniere/coverages/21072002/top8decks.html
Logged
Ruboonia
Guest
« Reply #5 on: July 23, 2002, 07:18:52 pm »

Great and fun to read tournament report!  Congrats at the tournament!
Logged
Rakso
Guest
« Reply #6 on: July 24, 2002, 02:25:55 am »

Those were amazing Ebony Charm stories.

I honestly wonder how seriously we should be looking at one of our own graveyard solutions again in the SB. Even makes Cunning Wish more attractive.

Then again, "The Deck" is something that wishes it had 20 sideboard slots!
Logged
CrazyCarl
Guest
« Reply #7 on: July 24, 2002, 03:13:37 am »

I'd love 20 sideboard slots.  I swear, I wouldn't EVER side in more than 10 of them lol ;\.  I'd just WISH for em ;D
Logged
Rakso
Guest
« Reply #8 on: July 24, 2002, 05:37:26 am »

By the way... someone tell me if I am mixing up Carl Devos and Carl Winters in my head.
Logged
NaClhv
Guest
« Reply #9 on: July 24, 2002, 05:53:56 am »

Right.  As opposed to 'the un-deck', which wishes it only had 5 sideboard slots.

But seriously, the "german tubbies" looks like a really good deck.  I haven't played with or against it myself, but the fact that you have to deal with both welders and survival while you're on a fast clock sounds pretty scary to me.

The dragon deck with bazaar sounds... weird to me.  My gut feeling tells me that since one of the advantage of dragon is its ridiculous speed, the bazaar-squee engine is not all that synergystic with it.  On the other hand, Dragon's one weakness is its lack of card drawing, so...  Well, I don't know what to think.  What were your impressions of that deck?

I must say, ebony charm is pretty cool.  Especially in your metagame, with grow and dragon and tubbies running all over.  Do you think it's better than a more extreme solution, like tormod's crypt?  How often do you use its other modes?
Logged
Grollub
Guest
« Reply #10 on: July 24, 2002, 06:07:04 am »

Quote from: NaClhv+July 24 2002,06:53
Quote (NaClhv @ July 24 2002,06:53)But seriously, the "german tubbies" looks like a really good deck.  I haven't played with or against it myself, but the fact that you have to deal with both welders and survival while you're on a fast clock sounds pretty scary to me.
Yeah. I agree it looks really really mean, what scares me the most is how well the deck seems to hang together..
Logged
Anonymous
Guest
« Reply #11 on: July 24, 2002, 09:04:52 am »

Yeah i started playing that tubbies deck about a month ago- until i read this article i was still debating about keeping in anger- but after a few more games of testing it really helps- this deck is quite amazing and anyone who want to play agaisnt it on apprentice email me at westredale@aol.com
Logged
Pages: [1]
  Print  
 
Jump to:  

Powered by MySQL Powered by PHP Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines Valid XHTML 1.0! Valid CSS!
Page created in 0.033 seconds with 17 queries.