YMTC 4

[evouga]

So now we're down to a bad Oversold Cemetary, vs. a win-more discard booster.

I can barely contain my excitement.

[Stormanimagus]

Yeah, this whole thing has been a ridiculous debacle. If Wizards can't see that they approved 10 awful cards for consideration then I really don't know what to say to that. It seems like the blind leading the blind there over at R & D sometimes. Ugh. For the record, my card would have been busted in Vintage if properly costed. It was:

Harr Mists

Enchantment

Spells you cast cost  less to cast where  is the storm count. 


This is a simple and elegant card that would not have broken any other formats if costed at something like  but would clearly have applications in Vintage Storm decks. Stephen Menendian's top 2 ideas were also quite good and neither got picked. I repeat, ridiculous.

This breaks my heart.

-Storm

[KrauserKrauser]

Consuming Contract was the only remaining design that sparked my interest.  The Megrim variant will likely win.  Megrim always has a ton of fans.

[vaughnbros]

Consuming Contract was the only remaining design that sparked my interest.  The Megrim variant will likely win.  Megrim always has a ton of fans.

My feelings as well.  I'm not sure either of the remaining designs even see standard play unless they are costed very aggressively.

[AmbivalentDuck]

The repeating Raise Dead may actually be playable if costed at IF they print a low CMC critter with flash and a relevant sac ability. It's not like it's hard to deal yourself damage with fetches.

[MaximumCDawg]

Well, Megrim won.  So much for this contest producing a vintage card.

[KrauserKrauser]

From Crucible to this, it appears the Magic community has gotten a bit less willing to embrace broken cards.

[KingSquee]

This may be a new piece of Dredge hate, if the mana cost is low enough.

But would it be better than what we already have? I think it could be. This card would help you defeat a Dredge pilot rather than just help you not lose.

[Wagner]

This may be a new piece of Dredge hate, if the mana cost is low enough.

But would it be better than what we already have? I think it could be. This card would help you defeat a Dredge pilot rather than just help you not lose.

Let's say it costs 1 black. Would it really be better than Planar Void?
They can still only use Bazaar 1-2 times and then dredge normally if they don't want to give you too many cards/dudes.

[AmbivalentDuck]

Dredge hate? Compost already exists. How is this better?