Necro's cards

[Fubar]

When cards are removed, normally or in response, with a necro, what happens to the cards removed in the event of disenchant or bounce?  Are they gone for good and can only be wished back?

[Luiggi]

I believe they go to your hand when they normally would if the Necro was still in play (i.e.- at end of turn), since Necro doesn't specify that it still has to be in play for the cards to go to your hand. This is why in old Necro decks, back in the day, you would typically Necro for a few cards before popping your Disk and getting rid of it. This is also the main reason why bounce/enchantment kill was never a great solution to Necro, because they can just Necro por some cards in response, draw those cards at end of turn and even get their regular draw step back! Quite a bargain, .

Luiggi

[epeeguy]

When cards are removed, normally or in response, with a necro, what happens to the cards removed in the event of disenchant or bounce?  Are they gone for good and can only be wished back?

The ability that removes the cards also sets up a delayed triggered ability that will put the card in your hand.  This is independent of Necropotence itself, and is just part of the ability that removes the card (so removing the Necropotence will not affect this triggered ability).  It is much like the ability of Kiki-Jiki or Astral Slide; it does something, then sets up the delayed triggered ability as well.

[Fubar]

So if i'm correct, there is no conceivable way to stop those cards from being put into hand @ EOT?

[Limbo]

So if i'm correct, there is no conceivable way to stop those cards from being put into hand @ EOT?

There is one, called Stifle, but it only stops one card per stifle, as each card removed creates a seperate trigger to be put in hand EOT.

[epeeguy]

So if i'm correct, there is no conceivable way to stop those cards from being put into hand @ EOT?

No, as Time Stop in response to the end of turn triggers (since all of them will go on the stack at the same time when the End of Turn Step begins) will prevent the cards from being put into the player's hand.

[Limbo]

Oops, I forgot that (obvious) one. Damn wizards and their development of new cards / ideas

[Fubar]

thanx