Yixlid Jailer and Flashback

[tehmajickguy]

If I have a Yixlid Jailer in play, do all my cards in my graveyard lose flashback?

[Ephraim]

Only the ones that had Flashback before Yixlid Jailer came into play.  The ones that didn't have it don't lose it.

[Grand Inquisitor]

Only the ones that had Flashback before Yixlid Jailer came into play.  The ones that didn't have it don't lose it.

This seems a little ambiguous to me.  You're saying that recoup on duress (after jailer), you can still play duress, but what if you discard a deep analysis after a jailer hits play?

[LotusHead]

Only the ones that had Flashback before Yixlid Jailer came into play.  The ones that didn't have it don't lose it.

This seems a little ambiguous to me.  You're saying that recoup on duress (after jailer), you can still play duress, but what if you discard a deep analysis after a jailer hits play?

Cards with Flashback lose Flashback.  Cards without Flashback didn't have Flashback in the first place to actually lose Flashback.  It was kind of a joke (being very technical on what can be "lost")

[Clariax]

This seems a little ambiguous to me.  You're saying that recoup on duress (after jailer), you can still play duress, but what if you discard a deep analysis after a jailer hits play?

It comes down to timestamps.  If the card has flashback itself, Jailer will remove that ability.  If some other effect starts after the Jailer is already in play giving a card flashback (like recoup), then that flashback will not be removed.  If after Recoup gives something flashback a Jailer comes into play, then that flashback given by the Recoup will be removed.