Angel of Jubilation

[Qasur]

Angel of Jubilation 1WWW
Creature - Ange
Flying
Other nonblack creatures you control get +1/+1.
Players can't pay life or sacrifice creatures to cast spells or activate abilities.
3/3

Although she costs 4 mana, I was curious what you guys thought of this angel? From first glace, she stops all phyrexian-mana spells (if you don't play matching colors, like MUD using Metamorph) and she also stops FOW too. The second part prevents Forgemaster from sacking itself to its ability as well as Tinkering off artifact-creatures.

My take is that she's probably too slow for Vintage as she only stops Metamorph and FoW.

Anyways, just looking for thoughts on her!

[boggyb]

1WWW

'nuf said bra! Too narrow and expensive even for white trash.

[Kiriyuu]

She stops the use of fetch lands too.

I guess she's just 1 mana too much for that to be useful, but it's worth considering.

[MaximumCDawg]

If she was a hate bear, I'd play her.  But she's a hate angel.  That's not as good.

[TheWhiteDragon]

Theoretically, is the same effect worth it as a 1/1 flier for 1W or WW?

[madmanmike25]

For 1W that would be awesome.  Great vintage-related ability.  Horrible casting cost.  The end.

[serracollector]

it is unforunately too expensive, but am I reading this wrong or does this work with Phyrexian Dreadnought?  since you can't sacrifice creatures?  wierd mechanic.

[Guli]

it is unforunately too expensive, but am I reading this wrong or does this work with Phyrexian Dreadnought?  since you can't sacrifice creatures?  wierd mechanic.

Phyrexian Dreadnought is a etb trigger. It is not an activated ability.

[Saya]

1WWW is too late to deny mana.She is unplayable.but yeah if she were WW bear,GW-hate or White Winnie might be delighted.

[Eastman]

Don't forget dredge. They can't dread return or cabal therapy which would slow them down a lot.

Too bad it doesn't shut off fastbond. That would maybe push it over the line. The tougheness is relevant for that white hate bear deck cuz it protects most of them from pyroclasm.  Kills your qasali pridemages though.