Opponent : his bob reveal 'tinker' and waiting for artifact to be sacrificed
Me : afraid so much for that 'tinker' and then cast demonic tutor to find duress
Me again : cast duress, and my opponent remind me that I already set one counter for my own Chalice of the Void. .

Legacy version for Imperial Painter has been popular all over the world and prove itself as one of the most competitive deck. .
I've been trying to convert this build into Vintage and comparing with your list, there's some differences :
1. Oopz, I forget about Gorilla Shaman (I use Viashino Heretic), I'll try at least 1. .
2. Vexing Susher is good, insane if your meta full with Chalice of the Void, 1 is enough. .
3. Dead/Gone?? WhoHOOO, I always love this card and I agree, 3 is the right number. .
4. Stingscourger doesn't needed, but it depends on your meta. .
5. Try Faerie Macabre, not as good as Tormod for graveyard hate, but this creatures is tutorable by Imperial. .
6. I don't know if spellshock is that good, I'll look it out
7. WHEEL of FORTUNE!! fit mana curve, dig more for Grindstone or other combo pieces, dig more mana producer, dig for protection (SSG + pyroblast as red Force of Will)

EDITED :
In Legacy area, anti-creature spell is everywhere, even Lightning Bolt can kill Paiter easily, but Grindstone usually get free. .
In Vintage area, artifact haters are everywhere so it'll be more difficult to protect both Painter and Grindstone, maybe I'll try for Welder in the future. .

It's a very similar theme with this build :
http://www.themanadrain.com/index.php?topic=35953.0

Let's talk there 

Do you mean you cast Demonic Consultation to tutor Balance??
Well, all this time I think tutoring a restricted card using Demon Consul is forbidden since it's super risky. .
But if someone have tried it and reach a lot of victory, I'll do it too 
In what condition this act should be done?

^
Also I don't like Cruicible. .Good, powerful, but usually don't have time to cast it or even weld it. .
But sensei is a good idea, I'd try. .

I've tried, all possible card in mind to make this deck more consistent. .
With tutors (Vampiric Tutor, Demonic Tutor, Imperial Seal, Demonic Consultation, even Gamble. .Entomb????)
Deck Thinners (fetchlands, street wraith). .
Drawer Engines (Dark Confidant, Bazaar + Squee, even Night Whisper). .
Spell Revival (Welder and Unearth). .
but still find that something missing to seal it as a competitive deck with consistency as the biggest issue. .

And I agree Welder is NOT a plan B, but I also realize that this build really needs a plan B (maybe aggro-way?)

EDIT :
This what I called 'aggro-way':
Grim Lavamancer
Boneshard Slasher
else?

same here 


agree 


Hurray 


Okay, let's get serious 
Your list looks solid, but I think my fave card Demonic Consultation is worth to have a place. .
Also I suggest for the legendary Jaya Balard, she's good against aggro thx to her incinerate ability. .
Also the 1st ability along with servant will make her a walking vindicate. .

In sideboard, with all people prediction Ichorid and Belcher will dominate the meta, maybe Thorn of Amethyst / Sphere will have a place to be thought. .

Agreed, I'll wait until the meta fixed and then build my mountain 

As a hate decks player, I assume I won't consider blue as strong opponent aspect again. .
it lefts me only aggro, non-blue combo, graveyard, and artifact. .

In my opinion, Threshold deck from legacy can be better than any blue based deck in vintage. .
At least legacy deck can be more stable. .

With the appearance of the new B/R list. .
We'll see how good Painter + Blast tech against the meta with no blue there. .

^
About Blessing, I think that's why blue archetype of servant deck contain 2-3 stifle at average. .

I'm still looking what are you people think about mirror match up, (Servant + 8 Red Blast vs Servant + 8 Red Blast). .
What strategy can be run since one player will be happy when another successfully cast his / her servant. .

Good point to include this combo to some old deck like Bomberman. .
Splashable really is servant / grindstone big advantage to be solid. .
Still waiting to see non-blue and non-workshop based to build. .

I'm waiting 
Because in my opinion, controlling with only 1 Grindstone as winning condition will be a hard time. .
We can't depend on Bob / Servant / SSG / Macabre as a beater anyway. .

-EDIT-

Owh yeah additional question just come in my mind. .
Since Painter's deck is everywhere this day, what's your plan against mirror?
Especially 'gush' and 'workshop' based type. .

Any more details about this match up?
I need to know how come possibility to put painter's servant + REB / Pyroblast tech into TMWA deck 

Tattermunge Maniac : say no, for RG beatz maybe
Fulminator Mage : owh yeah, the best card for TMWA in this expansion
Vexing Shusher : hmm, good but not that great, SB. .
Guttural Response : for TMWA which always contain  , REB and Pyroblast are simply better
Wheel of Sun and Moon : just interesting, useful? I don't think so. .
Runed Halo : for this time meta, yes. .
Ashenmoor Gouger : nope, vanilla. .
Farie Macabre : another grave-hate best tool, no color required, free, instant speed, owh thanks GOD!!
Firespout : no no no, TMWA is a creatures based deck. .
Smash to Smithereens : damage, not really necessary
Manamorphose : not for TMWA
Fossil Find : no comment. .
Heap Doll : with Extirpate, TOrmod's Crypt, Leyline of The Void, and brand new Farie Macabre, this one has no chance to glow

I'm sorry for asking. .
But is it work if we name Empty the Warrens?? Since Warren says : "Put two 1/1 red Goblin creature tokens into play.
Storm (When you play this spell, copy it for each spell played before it this turn.) "
Consider we name 'Goblin' as a name, will all goblin token's damages be prevented by Runed Halo?

This card made my eyes brighter :

===================================================================================
Runed Halo*     
Enchantment   Rare
As Runed Halo comes into play, name a card.
You have protection from the named card. (You can't be targeted by it, and all damage that would be dealt to you by it is prevented)
===================================================================================

Fit for this day meta? Yes, it's an anti for Goyf, Dryad, Dreadnought, even Darksteel Colossus won't crash it. .
As additional function this card also prevent you to lose from any tendril and brain freeze storm combo. .
(for Empty the Warren, I don't know if goblin token can be considered as a card??)

Cost for double white sure make it less playable, so. .??

Shadowmoor bring us some interesting creatures to be thought as possible army in TMWA style. .
They are :

Sygg, River Cutthroat      {ub}{ub}
Legendary Creature - Merfolk Rogue   Rare
At end of turn, if an opponent has lost 3 or more life this turn, you may draw a card. (Damage causes loss of life.)
Illus. Jeremy Enecio   #176/301   1/3

Blue-Black Hybrid so I assume TMWA only use her black side. .
She has no big impact for the metagame but with the right build (maybe with burn) we can use her as advantage. .


Fulminator Mage     1{br}{br}
Creature - Elemental Shaman   Rare
Sacrifice Fulminator Mage: Destroy target nonbasic land.
"Unsafe Terrain Ahead - Turn Back"
-Sign near the former location of Pyrtagh Cairn
Illus. R.K. Post   #188/301   2/2

What a nice black-red hybrid. .wasteland with legs to attack and block and possibility to re-use by creature revival spells. .

Vexing Shusher     {rg}{rg}
Creature - Goblin Shaman   Rare
Vexing Shusher can't be countered by spells or abilities.
{rg}: Target spell can't be countered by spells or abilities.
      2/2

Powerful, just awesome, walking Pyroblast I'd say. .

Here's my latest build for TMWA, please take a look 

Lands (17) :
4 Bloodstained Mire
1 Polluted delta
4 Badlands
1 Scrubland
1 Plateau
5 Swamp

Mana Artifacts (5) :
1 Mox Ruby
1 Mox Jet
1 Mox Pearl
1 Lotus Petal
1 Black Lotus

Artifacts (4) :
4 Aether's Vial

Creatures (20) :
4 Magus of The Moon
4 Jagget Poppet
4 Simian Spirit Guide
4 Gathan Riders
1 Aven Mindcensor
1 Jotun Grunt
2 Maralen of The Mornsong

Instant (10) :
1 Vampiric Tutor
1 Demonic Consultation
1 Hide/Seek
1 Extirpate
1 Snuff Out
2 Slaughter Pact
3 Pyrokinesis

Sorceries (4) :
4 Thoughtseize

The idea is same with standard BR TMWA with Jagget Poppet build plus I add  inside in order to put Maralen + Mincensor control. .
(stop gush, stop scroll, stop flash if it's not too late). .
With Maralen, Vial is a must, sure we don't want our opponents take the advantage first. .
And sure I don't add vial just for Maralen but we'll see how much effective its interaction with the others. .
Jotunt Grunt is there to recycle spell that used and search it again with Maralen. .

Very rough bulid?? Yes. .
Not tested well?? Yes. .
So I'm waiting for your criticism, be nice

If you run  for your deck, Hide/Seek will be a better option. .
Cranial's ability is there only to prevent Flash/Oath from their winning condition and you can find they will always one step ahead since  >  or 

Green is a competitive color this day since the present of Goyf. .
Everyone try to put it in as additional to be a faster clock or something. .
I myself find it's fun to play kind of 'Dawn of the Dead' aggro control deck. .

But as I remember from what TMWA's creator. .
This deck was called TMWA because :
1. It contains 
2. Say no to blue x x
3. Could be supported by other colors especially  and   
4. It's fun to play it. .

I'm not sure if we put green inside, this deck still can be TMWA type. .
Since it will be a brand new deck and maybe it'll have a brand new name too. .

One big issues that I want to make you remember is :
Previous TMWA thread was closed because it need to be refreshed. .
The 1st list from the 1st page is totally not similar with the last list that is discusses that time except for Moxen. .
So in my opinion, this thread is started by R/B TMWA (hellbent disruption style) and R/W TMWA (man prison style) or R/B/W (solution style). .
Maybe we can just start a discussion based on that fact. .

Just a thought from a TMWA fans and player. .

EDIT :
Tyrant Oath is in its golden age this time. .
The latest R/B version has handled GAT, Bomberman and many decks in the meta but still has many big problems to face Oath. .
What can we do about it?

--mancer--

Since you attack your opponent's manabase, will couples of sphere will be fit in this deck?
It'll be hard to cast something when you're running out of mana and your spell's cc is being increased. .

Old Goblins Deck (before Earwig's era) contain full set of Leyline of the Void and Magus of the Moon to play in main deck. .
Since GAT is dominating the meta now, LotV'd be remove to SB but MotM is still worthed though he isn't a goblin. .
Also I recommend for Thoughtseize / Duress (depend on your meta) > Therapies. .
Exact hand removal is better than 2x therapies experiment in my opinion. .
What do you all think about it?

Ringleaderless is okay but I can't imagine goblin deck without tutor, so between Matron and Recruiter, what do you like to prefer?
Also about Vial and off-color Mox, I'd test which is better. .

I played RB Goblins in my local vintage tourney last week and find similar case about Prowl Cost and Sphere. .
And based on my local judge's decision, I must pay one more when I want to play it with prowl way. .
So when Sphere of Resistance is in the play, Earwig Squad's prowl cost will be  . .
Prowl Cost is an alternate cost to play a spell, same as you pitch a blue card and pay 1 life for Force of Will. .

EDIT :
I don't know about the relation with Warchief, but my theory will say its prowl cost will be reduced with the same way. .

I've tried him and find he's good unless his casting cost. .
2 black is out of option except you find a fine manabase. .

Countryside Crusher is horrible for your list especially because it costs double red and you only run 16 lands (6 fetch?). .
In many case this giant won't be a monster, just vanilla creature 3/3 or 4/4. .

As Mr Polynomial P said about Oath match up :

4x Ray of Revelations because I want to see it in my opening hand. .Ray is the most powerful tool against oath beside all discard spells so it'll be fully needed in Oath metagame. .1 Ray usually destroy 1 Oath and pray it won't be extirpated until the opponent find another. .Ray make you don't have to fear drop your creature since this deck reach victory with them and there's no other way but creatures. .In average, 1 Tarmogoyf need 4 turn to beat into the death and Ray will give you that chance. .

Here's my report about my latest tourney (20/01/08 15.00-end) piloting this deck. .
It's only local tourney in my country and since not so many vintage players here, we've just 12 players and it means that 4 rounds to go. .
Only the top 3 get the prize and I finish on the 2nd place. .I have a good time and really enjoy it. .

Here's the list :

Maindeck :

Land (20) :
4  Bazaar of Baghdad
3  Bloodstained Mire
2  Windswept Heath
3  Bayou
2  Scrubland
1  Swamp
1  Riftstone Portal
3  Wasteland
1  Strip Mine

Artifact Mana (7) :
1  Mox Emerald
1  Mox Jet
1  Mox Ruby
1  Mox Pearl
1  Mox Diamond
1  Lotus Petal
1  Black Lotus

Creatures (17) :
4  Squee
4  Tarmogoyf
4  Dark Confidant
3  Gaddock Teeg
2  Jotun Grunt

Instant (5) :
4  Swords to Plowshares
1  Vampiric Tutor

Sorcery (10) :
1  Balance
2  Life from the Loam
4  Thoughtseize
3  Duress

Enchantment (1) :
1  Zombie Infestation

Sideboard (15) :
4  Thorn of Amethyst
4  Leyline of the Void
4  Ray of Revelation
2  Oxidize
1  Krosan Grip

Round 1 : vs Mr Rizal with U/R/B Fish

Game 1 - I lose the dice roll (13:15) and he leads with 1st turn Grim Lavamancer. .pass, and then I start my turn with 1st turn Dark Confidant with my only mox and only land with hope that I will draw more to find another mana base before his Lavamancer become active. .But in fact he waste my Scrubland, drop Mox Ruby and Bolt my Bob. .His next turn is eating my mox with Gorilla Shaman and beat me down till I lose. .
Game 2 - Play first, mulligan to 6 and have a fetch land search for Bayou and Black Lotus to have me cast Toughtseize -> discard his mancer -> drop a 3/4 Goyf. .at his turn he did nothing except drop a land and at my next turn I drop Bazaar -> draw 2 and pitch Balance, Vampiric Tutor, and Zombie Infestation -> Drop confidant. .he has no answer to 6/7 Goyf and it's an easy victory. .
Game 3 - He drop a fetch, drop Mog Fanatic, enter my turn, Duress his FoW away and win tha game with 2 4/5 Goyfs. .

[1-0]

Round 2 : vs Randy with Platinum and / or Tyrant Oath
Game 1 -  I lose the dice roll (13:15) and he has no oath but find a way to hard cast Platinum Angel (using Black Lotus) right after he Force my Thoughtseize. .then I Sword his Platinum, be countered by Pact of Negation, then I Sword it again (double kill!!), and he unable to pay that pact so he lose the game. .
Game 2 - He has 1st turn Oath + Orchard, revealing Tyrant (what the??). .enter my turn. .nothing's important. .and he grab me with Triskelavus - Tyrant combo at his next turn. .
Game 3 - Ray of Revelation really shines here. .and Goyf bring his into the death and give me my 2nd win for this day. .

[2-0]

Round 3 : vs Paulus with U/B/W Fish
Game 1 - I lose the dice roll (13:15 again???????). .and he starts with early confidant but I have a very wonderful hand. .1st turn drop Scrubland -> drop Black Lotus and get 3  mana to resolve mirror Confidant -> Toughtseize -> remove Jotun Grunt -> and then Sword his Bob. .
He drop Kataki and pass. .I reveal Mox Emerald -> draw Squee -> Drop Bazaar -> and then beat him since I win in creatures quantity. .
Game 2 - Loam and Wasteland are really shine here. .delay him until I have 3 4/5 Goyfs beat him. .thanks God his Jitte and Leyaline didn't appear tough I prepare enough Oxidize and Ray to prevent it. .

[3-0]

Round 4 : vs Mr Gani with Tyrant Oath
Game 1 - I lose the dice roll (13:19 4th appearance of 13. .owh no. .). .1st turn oath -> no answer -> active and nothing to be told. .
Game 2 - I keep my hand with 2 Ray but has no creatures in my hand, destroy 2 of his Oath but still has no creatures, playing Bazaar, draw for 2 and my 1st creature is Squee so I discard it away. .too bad it gets extirpated. .and then he has enough mana to cast Tyrant and Triskelavus to beat me down. .

[3-1]

After this tourney I just realize that all I faced today is just Oath and Oath. .Fish and Fish. .and perfect lose to dice rolls. .
Thanks for this thread and any advices to improve my skill using this deck. .too bad I have nothing to do with Zombie Infestation and Gaddock Teeg is always being Forced. .

*this performance, result, and report are dedicated to my friend's younger brother who passed away 8 days ago. .
(I choose to play this deck simply because I was unable to bring my own cards which laid in his house. .so I borrowed cards from many people, built this deck, and find a fine result. .may his soul and spirit rest in peace. .)

Good article. .I always love to use Sensei in my Staxless Stax deck since it has good trick with Welder, Ravager or Shrapnel Blast. .
I'll be more excited if this article tell me more info about Bazaar of Bagdad and trick to use it for advantage. .

Plus mirror. .cause I'll have more aggressive strategy when I face another deck which contain wire n stack. .

I'll play this deck on the next tourney this weekend, any advice?
I think I would play Polynomial P's list with 1 Extirpate maindeck for ???? slot. .
*note : my meta has highly Oath and Stax. .so revelation will definitely 4 on the board. .