I think the issue is that you haven't given concrete evidence as to why the omission of black is superiour to running a number of restricted black cards. While the hesitation to run a mana base that is susceptible to wasteland is some-what understandable, you have shown nothing to offset the tournament data generated before the June 2008 restrictions which shows the undeniable strengths of gush featuring black. Most discussions that aim to be productive here are result-based discussions detailing match ups and tournament reports. Without being much more long winded about this, I think you'll convince others of the viability of UG Gro when you can enequivocally show that this deck can outperform a more traditional Gush deck with the ability to go broken with YagWill.
--------
Edit: forests explained what I was trying to express more verbosely and without the restrictions of typing on a phone
