My deck is proxy free, but I ran proxies for about one year when I first got into Vintage. Without proxies I would not have started playing in the format.

I really like this strategy--I'm glad it paid off! The deck seems really well positioned right now. I think forcing Mentor decks to respond to a huge threat is exactly what Landstill needed, well done!!!

 


Will there be alter artists here again?

Last year Sandreline Moussé did these phenomenal alters for me:

DISPUTE SETTLED!

It would be really cool to have just one section designated for EDH, cube, '93/'94, etc. A lot of people play EDH but it's difficult to find who does or has time to play at any given moment in large events.

What if we had one long table that was reserved specifically for these other formats? Just a large sign at a table would suffice--no need to even have someone coordinating side events. That way in between rounds or if people drop out they could go to this table and find others willing to spend time playing EDH or something.

Thoughts?

Does anyone have recommendations of different deck lists or archetypes I should try in Old School Magic? I'd like to play grindy control/prison style decks. I mostly play Landstill in Vintage and like to dabble with Shops. Feel free to PM me, thanks!

I really want to get in on this format, seems awesome.

You should share a picture of "Ojutai."

False, Dredge is on the back of the playmat.

Tom came to mind for me as well for someone that's a Vintage generalist. Also, my perspective is that Tom is a talker (I mean this in a good way) and his commentary would be a nice addition to VSL. During tournaments he's always open to me with his deck list and reasoning behind choices.





Reid would be a really smart choice for VSL. They would benefit from someone that is proven across many formats and still knows Vintage. Also, Reid had the cojones to run TPS in the shops-infested North East during Champs. He's also a nice guy.





I like this choice a lot since Brian Kelly doesn't have the "star power" they're looking for. It's sometimes boring to watch some of the VSL competitors rotate archetypes amongst themselves (Delver, Belcher, Merfolk). I'd love to see someone abuse the vast card selection of the format.

Nice work, Schmuckles. I'm happy that you're getting into the format. Let's do Vintage at Stomping Grounds!

Interesting, I use KMC because I always split Dragon Shields. We should watch each other shuffle!

1) Mark Tocco.
-World Champ
-Proven record with a variety of archetypes
-Has successfully done commentary before (in Legacy)
-He's a local to my area, so I'm partial
-Everyone likes tacos

2) Any of the major tournament organizers (Calvin Hodges, Nick Coss, etc. )
-I feel that TO's/dealers are just as important as the players to keep Vintage thriving

3) Reid Duke
-Has many accolades as a Magic player
-As with most people on VSL, he's a versatile player when it comes to archetypes
-He could attract more people to Vintage



Honorable mention: Brian Kelly because he is a successful brewer. However, I feel that VSL looks for players with bigger stats (e.g. hall of famers or a lot of pro points). Also, players aren't on the mic when they duel so we wouldn't hear Brian maniacally laughing when he's casting something ridiculous.

Disclaimer: This is just for fun and is no way meant to impact the VSL.


I've been seeing a lot of sweet decks in VSL that have been pioneered by a lot of people in TMD community. I think this showcases just how versatile Vintage can be to the many viewers that are unfamiliar with the format.

I personally enjoy brewing more than anything, so I'd love to see some of our brewers invited to the League. Everyone enjoys different aspects of Magic more than others, so...


  Who are three (3) players that you would like to see invited to VSL and why? (Cannot list yourself)

Were your comfortable with the amount of permission in the main?

Also, do you think the number of "game changers" felt right or would you change it at all?

Lastly, were you able to test punishing fire much against mentor?

Very impressive finish, Matt.


This is really good input. I was on UWR Landstill and my dredge hate was 3 Grafdigger's Cage and 3 Containment Priest (and I'd probably side in an Ingot Chewer). I don't really test against Dredge but you've made me reconsider graveyard sweepers.

I had a blast! (Even though I scrubbed pretty hard).

Also, you had an amazing lineup of alter artists! I can't wait to get my commissions back from Sandreline!

Great job on the list. I like how this list personifies "vintage" a lot more than many other mentor lists, although I was expecting something like a Narset, Enlightened Master in the 75 

Awesome report, Lance. How was Punishing Fire performing in round 2.5?

I'm glad that players are embracing more of the archetypes that separate Vintage from Legacy (DDay, shops, etc.).

I'm a proponent of non-violent Magic and it pains me to see creatures turning sideways and attacking.

Has anyone experienced a high amount of angry people on MTGO? Seems like the good sportsmanship of the paper vintage community has not transferred to MTGO whatsoever.

I'm highly interested in such an event but I'm on vacation on this date. Count me in for future events.

I'd personally play for the Lotus--it looks amazing!

Altru on MTGO

So sad, I can't make it to this tournament and you might be whipping out the rituals 

p.s. you should play gifts too!

Is anyone willing to loan out an extra deck? If so please let me know via private message. My brother would like to play but neither of us have a deck for him. Thanks!

I am not speaking on behalf of the TO, but I do see the following guidelines quite often for other tournaments (p.s. welcome to vintage!):





Please do not use the back of a magic card for a proxie!

There are two types of acceptable proxies. The first and most basic is taking a basic land card and writing the details of the card on it. The second method is to take a card that shares some of the characteristics with the card that is being proxied and erase any characteristics that do not match, replacing them with the correct characteristics.

All proxies must have the following text neatly printed, using a extra fine point sharpie. Ball point pens may not be used:
• The full name of the card (no abbreviations or nicknames)
• Correct casting cost of the card including all colored mana symbols
• All relevant/game effecting text

When choosing what card to use as the base for an erased proxy players must follow these rules:
• The mana cost of the base spell must be the same as the card being proxied.
• The type of the card being proxied must be the same as the base card.
• The P/T of a creature being proxied must be the same as the base creature P/T
• When proxying a creature it may be difficult to find a creature where all characteristics match. In this case, mana cost is the most important, followed by the P/T, followed by the subtype. Any characteristics that do not match must be erased and corrected.
• The art box, card name, and text box must be totally erased. White out may not be used for this as it affects the stiffness of the card and may mark it.
• When adding text to the card do not use a ball point pen. A extra fine point sharpie is the best thing to use. A ball point pen can cause indentations on the card marking it.
• For clarity reasons, the use of cards with the new card frame is strongly encouraged

A mox and side events? 

How do you feel like the deck performs with such few permission cards?

Excellent work, Josh. I was really hoping you, me, or Lance would make it all the way. You had an impressive performance nonetheless! You can always take it down next year